January+17,+2012+-+Yagelski+Response

January 16, 2012 “Literacy in Our Lives” by Robery Yagelski Chapter 2 – //Literacy Matters//

Yagelski’s opening observation regarding his parents’ differing viewpoint toward the two boys was very common for the time period and social class that Yagelski was growing up in. However, he stated that he felt that as he grew in his academic success that the chasm between him and his parents grew as well, due to their inability to relate to his newfound intellect through literature. I question if you could directly state that the distance was from that or if it was more of a naturally occurring distance that most children have as they grow into independent thinking adults. Although, I do agree that there is a possibility of losing your cultural identity along the way, whether intentionally or unintentionally. Regarding Yagelski’s viewpoint on literacy and individuality, I do agree that educators are required to see if student writers can perform various functions and test them on these standards. I can understand his frustration, but I also recognize that the type of writing he desires to see can be done in the classroom. For the first time in the four years since I have been teaching 7th grade, this year’s MEAP writing prompts focused around student interests compared to the last few years. This type of prompt allowed, to some degree, for them to include their experiences and background, achieving some individuality. The reality is they do have to be able to perform these skills to be college ready, and in today’s global marketplace the competition for jobs is intense.